All comments posted by Depthsofchaos :

This contest is all about who can get more friends to dl their replays and rate them high. Not to mention those who uploaded replays in the beginning will have them on the top list, and not because of the quality. But whatever, the site is still good.

You should really only give XP for guides cause this is right now a "who got more time and the least pride to create accounts then use proxy to rate his own replays "contest which I hope you don't want it to be.

Just check any high rated replay recently uploaded, painfuly obvious, the dummy accounts don't upload any replays, have a lot of useless comments and they've registered after the contest. You could ban silentdeath right away if you cared about cheating..